Articles

How SpaceX Lands Rockets with Astonishing Accuracy


For the past decade, the entire world has
had their eyes on SpaceX as they have revolutionized rocket engineering and space travel.
From launching a sports car into orbit, to the promise of establishing a futuristic colony
on mars, their spectacles have generated levels of public excitement and media coverage that
haven’t been seen since NASA’s Apollo program which ended more than 40 years ago.
At the core of their ambitious plans is one of the greatest technological developments
in the history of rocket engineering: reusable rockets.
First announced to the public in 2011, the SpaceX reusable launch system development
program set out to create a new generation of launch vehicles that would drastically
reduce the cost of reaching orbit. To accomplish this, SpaceX proposed the seemingly
impossible task of recovering rocket boosters using powered-descent.
Their goal was to develop a rocket that could be launched vertically to deliver a payload
into orbit, and then return back to earth with a controlled descent and vertical landing
at a pre-determined landing site. Either on land, or on an autonomous floating
drone ship. In just 7 years, SpaceX was not only able
to achieve their goal of creating such a rocket, but they have proven that their system is
both reliable and economical with more than 60 successful launches and 30 successful landings
of their Falcon 9 boosters, along with a 100% success rate since the completion of their
experimental testing program. Or at least that was the case until December
2018, but at least they had a pretty good run.
17 of their boosters were also re-used on successive missions, and their unit cost for
launching a kg of payload into orbit has been reduced to just a fraction of the nearest
competitor. But how exactly did SpaceX accomplish this,
and how do they manage to land 70 m tall rockets weighing in excess of ½ a million kilograms
precisely on a 50 m wide landing pad after they are launched more than 70 km into the
atmosphere at speeds exceeding 8,000 km/h? It all comes down to just 2 key things: experience,
and ridiculously well-engineered rockets. Let’s start with experience by taking a
brief look at the history of the reusable launch system development program.
The program itself was first announced in 2011, but it wasn’t until late 2015 that
SpaceX was able to land a Falcon 9 booster on land successfully, and it took several
years beyond this to achieve a respectable landing success rate.
Before this, SpaceX spent 5 years conducting experimental landings where they tested their
new technologies and learned how to build better rockets through trial and error.
They began with a prototype vertical takeoff and vertical landing vehicle called Grasshopper,
which completed 8 successful flights from 2012 to 2013.
Following the initial success of Grasshopper, SpaceX then equipped their first Falcon 9
boosters for powered-descent and conducted several soft landings on the ocean surface
from 2013 to early 2015. Unfortunately, these first tests with the
Falcon 9 were only able to achieve a landing accuracy of about 10 km, but this was greatly
improved in future tests. When the first landings on an autonomous floating
drone ship were attempted later in 2015, SpaceX endured a series of public failures as 4 consecutive
barge landings failed quite dramatically. Despite these failures, they obtained valuable
data from every single flight, and they used the failures as opportunities to learn from
their mistakes in order to develop a more robust landing system.
SpaceX continued to perform Falcon 9 landing tests through 2015 and 2016, both on drone
ships and on land, and successful landings became routine by early 2017, with SpaceX
deciding to stop referring to their landing attempts as experimental.
From the beginning of 2017 to nearly the end of 2018, SpaceX maintained a 100% landing
success rate with a minimum landing accuracy of just 10 m.
This impressive accuracy represents a 1000-fold improvement compared to the initial soft-landing
tests which were only able to land within a 10 km radius from the intended target.
But how did SpaceX manage to increase the landing accuracy of their rocket boosters
by 10,000% in just 4 years? Obviously, this wasn’t achieved through
experience alone, and so this brings us to point number 2: ridiculously well-engineered
rockets. When SpaceX performs a rocket launch with
the Falcon 9, the rocket separates into two stages in Earth’s upper atmosphere.
The second stage of the rocket carries the payload into space, while the first stage
booster returns to Earth and lands at a landing site for re-use.
The booster is programmed to follow a precise flight path back to Earth, and it must autonomously
perform a series of controlled maneuvers in order to maintain that path and land vertically
on the landing pad. The exact flight path depends on whether the
rocket is landing on a floating drone ship in the ocean, or on land, and for landings
at sea there is the added complexity of ensuring that the drone ship is in the correct position
when the rocket touches down. However, the greatest engineering challenge
by far is building a rocket capable of performing the maneuvers that are necessary for controlled
descent and landing. After stage separation occurs, the rocket
booster re-orients itself and performs a boost back burn to achieve the proper trajectory
towards Earth. During the descent, it performs a re-entry
burn which is used to reduce its velocity. As the booster approaches the landing site,
it re-orients itself again so that it is in line with the landing pad, it deploys its
landing legs, and it performs a landing burn to bring its velocity to zero as it touches
down on the pad. During the entire flight, from stage separation
to landing, the rocket continuously measures its orientation and velocity, and it adjusts
its trajectory accordingly so that it maintains the correct flight path.
To accomplish all of this, SpaceX has implemented several rocket technologies that were developed
and refined through their experimental testing program, and it’s these technologies that
have been pivotal to the development of their reusable high-accuracy rockets.
The six key technologies incorporated into the Falcon 9 rocket booster are as follows:
1) Thrust vector control. The merlin rocket engines of the first stage
booster are gimbaled using hydraulic actuators so that the direction of thrust can be adjusted.
This is a method of thrust vectoring that can be used to control the orientation of
the rocket both within Earth’s atmosphere and outside of Earth’s atmosphere where
aerodynamic control surfaces such as fins are ineffective.
Thrust vectoring is actually a common technology that is used for rockets, as well as military
aircraft and missiles, however it is absolutely necessary for the maneuverability of the Falcon
9. 2) Cold gas thrusters.
The Falcon 9 is equipped with a total of 8 nitrogen cold gas thrusters that are mounted
towards the top of the first stage. There is 1 pod on each side of the rocket,
each containing 4 thrusters. Like the gimbaled main engines, the cold gas
thrusters are used to control the orientation of the rocket.
They are particularly useful for the flip maneuver after stage separation because of
the large lever arm between the thrusters and the rocket’s center of mass.
They are also used to control the rocket at times during flight when the gimbaled main
engines are shut off. 3) Re-ignitable engines.
Since the first stage must perform three separate burns after stage separation, it is necessary
for the main rocket engines to be re-ignitable. The engines of the first stage booster have
therefore been designed so that they can re-ignite in the upper atmosphere at supersonic speeds
as well as in the lower atmosphere at transonic speeds.
4) Inertial navigation and global positioning systems.
The Falcon 9 is equipped with an inertial navigation system, or INS, that uses several
types of sensors to measure the position, orientation, and velocity of the vehicle.
A global positioning system, or GPS, is also used to measure geolocation.
The onboard computer receives data from the INS and GPS in real-time and checks this information
against the pre-programmed flight path. If the computer detects any deviations from
the flight path, then it instructs the rocket to adjust its orientation and velocity as
necessary. 5) Deployable landing gear.
In order to perform vertical landings, the Falcon 9 is equipped with 4 lightweight landing
legs that are deployed using high-pressure helium just before touchdown.
Each leg is constructed from carbon fiber and aluminum, and contains an impact attenuator
for particularly hard landings. The total span of the deployed landing gear
is approximately 18 m, and the entire landing system weighs less than 2,100 kgs.
6) Deployable grid fins. Four titanium grid fins are mounted at the
top of the first stage booster, and are deployed during the rocket’s descent back into Earth’s
lower atmosphere. The fins are aerodynamic control surfaces
that are used for precise control of the rocket’s position and orientation prior to landing.
The four grid fines alone are primarily responsible for the incredible 10 m landing accuracy of
the Falcon 9 first stage booster. Grid fins were first used on the fifth soft-landing
attempt of the reusable launch system development program in 2015, and iterations on their design
were continued through 2017 in order to achieve the accuracy that we see from SpaceX today.
So in the end, SpaceX was able to employ experience and good engineering to develop a reusable
and highly accurate launch vehicle, the Falcon 9.
The Falcon 9 is an astonishing feat of modern engineering, and I hope that it sets a precedent
for the future of space travel. Without a doubt, the development of a reusable
launch system has been one of the greatest technological developments in the history
of rocket engineering, and I can’t wait to see what the future has in store for SpaceX.
Or perhaps I should rather say, what SpaceX has in store for the future. I really hope that you enjoyed this video, and I hope that I was able to provide some insight into the landing technology used by SpaceX.
Please remember to subscribe if you would like to stay up to date with future content,
and feel free to leave suggestions for future videos in the comments below.
You can also support this channel on Patreon using the link in the description, which helps
me to improve my videos and grow the channel. Thanks for watching, and I’ll see you in
the next video.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *